Mutual Funds and Taxes: A Primer to Help Lighten the Load

Mutual Funds and Taxes

A look at potential tax consequences of mutual fund investing, including the calculation of cost basis for capital gains.

 

Unless your mutual fund investment is held in a tax-deferred vehicle like a 401(k) plan or IRA, you are responsible for paying taxes on any dividends and capital gains distributions made by the fund during the year; reinvesting these distributions in the fund does not relieve you of this tax burden. You must also pay taxes on any capital gains on the sale or exchange of shares in your account.

Taxable distributions from mutual funds come in three forms: dividends, short-term capital gains, and long-term capital gains. Qualified dividends are taxed at a maximum rate of 20%. Short-term capital gains from assets sold within 12 months of their purchase are taxed at your regular income tax rate. Long-term gains are currently taxed up to a maximum of 20%.

Remember that each dollar of capital loss can offset a dollar of capital gain. Should your losses exceed your gains, you can offset up to $3,000 of ordinary income. Losses beyond $3,000 can be carried over and deducted from income in future years. To figure out your taxable gain or loss, you’ll need to determine your adjusted cost basis in the shares, using one of several different methods. If you hold multiple shares of different funds, you should take care to keep good records — especially year-end statements — and remember to factor in sales loads when calculating cost basis.

 

Key Points that we will review and explain:

  • Tax Treatment of Mutual Funds
  • How to Determine a Gain or Loss
  • Four Ways to Determine Cost Basis
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Some Helpful Hints
  • Points to Remember

Filling out your tax return is like compiling the index of a book — the book is complete, but you have to rummage (sometimes painfully) through your work again, assuring accuracy and factual content, in order to make the book easier for someone else to read. If you’re a mutual fund investor trying to determine your taxable gain or loss for the past year, your tax return will entail additional work.

But if you’ve kept good records and understand some basic guidelines, the process can be relatively painless.

Tax Treatment of Mutual Funds

The first step in evaluating your tax liability is knowing which investment transactions require payment of taxes. In general, whenever you sell or exchange shares of a mutual fund, you may have a capital gain or loss that must be reported in the tax year of the transaction. In addition, most funds receive periodic dividend or interest income from stock or bond investments and incur capital gains or losses when selling securities in the fund during the year. The fund company passes these dividends, interest, and capital gains to you, the shareholder, either in a check or through reinvested distributions. You must pay taxes on dividends, interest, and capital gains that the fund company distributes to you, in addition to capital gains on sale or exchange of shares in your account. Reinvesting distributions in more shares of the fund does not relieve you from having to pay taxes on those distributions. 

The next step is understanding the difference between short- and long-term capital gains. Short-term capital gains (assets held 12 months or less) are taxed at your regular income tax rate, whereas long-term capital gains (assets held for more than 12 months) are currently subject to federal tax at a rate of up to 20%.1 Remember that each dollar of capital loss can offset a dollar of capital gain. In other words, if you have $1,000 in long-term gains and $600 in long-term losses, you only have to pay tax on a net long-term gain of $400. Should your losses exceed your gains, you can offset up to $3,000 of excess capital losses against ordinary income. Losses beyond $3,000 can be carried over and deducted from income in future years.

How to Determine a Gain or Loss

In order to determine whether you have a gain or loss on a sale or exchange, you must first know your “adjusted cost basis.” That’s because you will be taxed on the difference between the cost basis of the fund shares and the amount you received when you sold them.

Under a federal law that took effect on January 1, 2011, financial institutions are now required to report cost basis for certain investments to investors, on Form 1099-B, which typically is made available to investors in January of the following year. The expanded Form 1099-B specifies whether a gain or loss was short term or long term. The new cost-basis reporting requirements took effect for certain securities in 2011, and apply to mutual fund shares purchased on or after January 1, 2012.

Previously, when an investor sold a position in a security or a fund, the investor’s financial firm was required to report only the gross sale proceeds to the investor and to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). It was typically up to the investor to track the cost basis and to calculate the capital gain or loss, and the resulting tax liability, for income tax purposes. The IRS always gave you the choice of accounting methods to determine cost basis.

FIFO, which stands for “first in, first out,” means the shares you bought first are also the ones you sell first.

The specific identification method of selling shares demands more planning on your part, but also provides the most flexibility of any method for determining the amount of gain or loss on your shares. For example, if you want to select certain shares to sell in order to produce the best tax benefit for your situation, you have to specify the shares you want to sell in advance and in writing to your fund company. Then, you’ll receive confirmation of your request for your tax records. Therefore, if you’ve sold shares of a fund in the past year, and didn’t specify which shares, it’s too late to use this method for that particular fund. You can, however, use specific identification in the future, as long as you haven’t previously employed the single- or double-category average cost method.

The average cost method calculates your cost basis by simply averaging the purchase price of all your shares, regardless of how long you have held them. This method is particularly time-saving if you are redeeming or exchanging all shares of a fund account and have invested over many years and reinvested your dividends. But the tax result may not be advantageous if you’re only redeeming a portion of the account.

 

Mutual Funds and Taxes graphic

Most financial institutions use average cost as the default tax lot identification method for mutual funds, but you should check before making this assumption. Note that you may still select the cost basis reporting method you prefer.  Speak to a Fee Only Financial Advisor about how your specific situation is treated.  

Other Factors to Consider

Keep in mind that you can’t change to another method at a future date without permission from the IRS once you’ve chosen single- or double-category averaging for a particular fund. Also, you must specifically state on your return if you are using one of the averaging methods. These restrictions are not placed on shareholders using either the FIFO or specific identification method of selling shares.  If you are unsure of how those restriction apply to you, contact your Fee Only Financial Planner.

If you buy shares of a fund that has a front-end load, the sales charge is included in the cost basis of those shares. Therefore, if you send your fund company $1,000 to purchase shares that have a 5% load up front, your account would be worth $950. However, your cost basis would still be $1,000 for tax purposes. If your fund company charges a load when you sell your shares, the load should be deducted from your gain or added to your loss. For example, if you invested $1,000 in a fund and sold those shares later for $2,000 with a 2% back-end load, your gain on those shares would be $1,000 minus the load of $40 (2% of $2,000), or $960.

Also note that when you purchase additional shares as a result of reinvesting dividends and capital gains, such shares are included in your cost basis. And if you’re thinking about taking losses this year in order to offset other gains, keep in mind that you cannot sell shares at a loss and buy additional shares in the same or substantially identical mutual fund within 30 days before or after the date of sale. The applicable federal tax law treats that as a “wash sale.”

Some Helpful Hints

There’s no substitute for keeping careful records of all mutual fund investments. Especially important are year-end statements, which generally list the past year’s transactions, including dividends and capital gains distributions. If you’re missing records for any year, ask your fund company to supply them. They’ll be indispensable when preparing your tax return in future years when you sell those shares.

The above guidelines can provide you with some sense of direction as you plan to compile your “index” of taxable transactions from the past year. Of course, you may want to consult a tax advisor regarding your particular situation to ensure that you are making the decisions that are best for you. It can never hurt to have someone “edit” the masterpiece you’ve created.

Points to Remember

  1. Shareholders must pay taxes on dividends and capital gains distributions made to them during the year; reinvesting distributions does not relieve the shareholder from tax burdens.
  2. Short-term capital gains are monetary gains from assets sold within one year of their purchase. Long-term capital gains are monetary gains from assets sold more than one year after their purchase.
  3. Short-term capital gains are taxed at the investor’s ordinary income tax rate. Long-term capital gains are taxed up to the maximum capital gains rate.
  4. Under the FIFO method of calculating cost basis, the first shares purchased are the first shares sold.
  5. Under the specific identification method of determining cost basis, the shareholder chooses which shares to sell to obtain the maximum tax benefit. Prior written notification must be given to the fund company of the shares to be sold, and confirmation of that request should be obtained.
  6. Under the single-category average cost method of determining cost basis, shareholders average the purchase prices of all shares in the account, regardless of how long they’ve been held.
  7. A law that took effect in 2011 requires financial institutions to begin to report cost basis for certain investments to investors, on Form 1099-B, which typically is made available to investors in January of the following year. For mutual fund investors, the new rule applies to shares purchased on or after January 1, 2012.
  8. Sales loads must be considered when determining cost basis.
  9. “Wash sale” rules prohibit shareholders from claiming a loss on sold shares (or substantially similar shares) that are repurchased within 30 days before or after the date of sale.

Source/Disclaimer:

1An additional 3.8% Medicare contribution tax may also apply to certain capital gains.

Eric Simonds is a Portland, ME Fee-Only Financial Planner located in Brunswick and serving clients across the country. Saltwater Harbor Financial LLC specializes in providing objective financial planning to help clients build, manage, grow, and protect their assets through life’s transitions. Eric Simonds is a NAPFA-Registered Financial Advisor and a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ Professional, who appears on the Paladin Registry.

Because of the possibility of human or mechanical error by Wealth Management Systems Inc. or its sources, neither Wealth Management Systems Inc. nor its sources guarantees the accuracy, adequacy, completeness or availability of any information and is not responsible for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from the use of such information. In no event shall Wealth Management Systems Inc. be liable for any indirect, special or consequential damages in connection with subscriber’s or others’ use of the content.

© 2016 Wealth Management Systems Inc. All rights reserved.

About

Eric Simonds has a passion for helping others. Over the past 12 years, Eric has gained his skills and credentials through both private and public sector careers in policy and compliance. This experience, in addition to his Masters of Financial Planning from Golden Gate University, allows him to provide quality financial planning to all Maine families through Saltwater Harbor. Eric takes great pride in operating his own financial planning practice, knowing he makes a difference in the lives of his clients. His motivation for success is fueled by his clients’ accomplishments and ability to achieve their financial dreams with his guidance.

Eric is both a 2011 National Huguenot Scholarship recipient and the sole 2012 National Association Professional Financial Advisors Merit Scholar. In addition to his Masters in Financial Planning, Eric also holds Bachelor degrees from both the University of Maine and the University of Southern Maine. Highly involved in his local community and family, he resides in Brunswick with his wonderful wife, Kate, their two amazing sons, two naughty dogs and a cat.